Cons of Symbol Server

Symbol servers are great. However I found that in crash dump analysis the absence of automatically loaded symbols sometimes helps to identify a problem or at least gives some directions for further research. It also helps to see which hot fixes or service packs for your product were installed on a problem computer. The scenario I use sometimes when I analyze crash dumps from product A is the following:

  1. Set up WinDbg to point to Microsoft Symbol Server
  2. Load a crash dump and enter various commands based on the issue. Some OS or product A components become visible and their symbols are unresolved.
  3. From unresolved OS symbols I’m aware of the latest fixes or privates from MS
  4. From unresolved symbols of the product A and PDBFinder I determine the base product level and this already gives me some directions.
  5. I add the base product A symbols to symbol file path and continue my analysis.
  6. If unresolved symbols of the product A continue to come up I use PDBFinder again to find corresponding symbols and add them to symbol file path. By doing that I’m aware of the product A hot fix and/or service pack level.
  7. Also from the latest version of PDBFinder (3.0.1) I know whether there are any updates to the component in question.

Of course, all this works only if you store all PDB files from all your fixes and service packs in some location(s) with easily identified names, for example, PRODUCTA\VER20\SP31\FIX01. Adding symbols manually helps to be focused on components, gives attention to some threads where they appear. You might think it is a waste of time but it only takes very small percentage of time especially if you look at the dump for a couple of hours.

What is PDBFinder? This is a program I developed to be able to find right symbol files (especially for minidumps). It scans all locations for PDB or DBG files and adds them to a text database. Next time you run PDBFinder it loads that database and you can find PDB or DBG file location by specifying module name and its date. You can also do a fuzzy search by specifying some date interval. If you run it with -update command line option it will build the database automatically, useful for scheduling weekly updates.  

The public version of PDBFinder Deluxe 2.2.1 can be downloaded from Citrix support web site. The new version 3.0.1 on the way with major improvements and will be announced tomorrow.

- Dmitry Vostokov -

One Response to “Cons of Symbol Server”

  1. Dmitry Vostokov Says:

    Version 3.6 is available:

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.